Audioengine A2+ vs. Edifier R1700BT
|Audioengine A2+ Wireless Bluetooth Speakers
|Edifier R1700BT Bluetooth Bookshelf Speakers
|Dimensions (H × W × D)
6.00” × 4.00” × 5.25”
152mm × 102mm × 133mm
9.75” × 6.00” × 8.00”
248mm × 152mm × 203mm
TLDR Summary: In the realm of compact desktop speakers, the Audioengine A2+ Wireless and Edifier R1700BT stand out for their blend of size and sonic performance. The A2+ offers crisp, clear audio with built-in DAC for enthusiasts seeking a high-quality wired connection, plus the convenience of Bluetooth. Edifier's R1700BT, with its classic wood finish, brings a warm, robust sound and dynamic bass, making it a favorite for those who favor a more laid-back listening experience. Both speakers deliver beyond their size, yet the choice between them hinges on personal preference for audio signature and aesthetic appeal.
When it comes to compact, high-quality speakers that are versatile enough for a variety of audio needs, the Audioengine A2+ Wireless and Edifier R1700BT are two standout options that often come under scrutiny. Both are celebrated for their ability to deliver impressive sound from small enclosures, and each has its own loyal following. In dissecting their qualities and performance, one can appreciate the subtle art of speaker design and how it influences our listening experiences.
Design and Build Quality
The Audioengine A2+ Wireless speakers exude a minimalist charm with their clean lines and no-frills aesthetic. They are solidly built, with a hand-finished wood cabinet that not only provides a warm look but also contributes to their excellent acoustic properties. On the other hand, the Edifier R1700BT boasts a more contemporary design with a side panel of controls adding to its modern flair. The walnut vinyl finish gives it a sophisticated edge that can easily blend into a range of home decors. Both sets of speakers feel robust, but the Audioengine's classic style may appeal more to those with a taste for timeless design.
The 'Wireless' in Audioengine A2+ Wireless hints at its modern connectivity, and these speakers don't disappoint. They feature Bluetooth aptX, allowing for high-quality streaming from compatible devices. Moreover, they come with a variety of inputs including a USB audio input, dual analog audio inputs, and even a subwoofer output. The Edifier R1700BT also comes with Bluetooth connectivity, ensuring you can play music from most Bluetooth-enabled devices. However, they lack USB input, which may be a downside for users who prefer a digital direct connection when streaming audio from their computers.
The sound signature of the Audioengine A2+ Wireless speakers is one of clarity and detail. They boast kevlar woofers and silk tweeters that deliver a balanced sound across frequencies. The bass response is tight and punchy, given the speakers' compact size, and they handle high frequencies with finesse, avoiding any harshness. In contrast, the Edifier R1700BT speakers are equipped with a 4-inch bass driver and a 19mm dome tweeter that produce a warm, rich sound. They offer a more pronounced bass response, which might be preferable for genres such as hip-hop or electronic music. However, some might find the bass to be a bit overwhelming, potentially overshadowing the mids and highs.
Another aspect to consider is the soundstage and imaging. The Audioengine A2+ Wireless speakers create an expansive soundstage that belies their small footprint. They project audio with precision, making it easy to pinpoint instruments within a track. The Edifiers also provide an impressive soundstage, but they may not have the same level of precision as the Audioengines when it comes to imaging.
Compare to similar speakers
Both sets of speakers exhibit minimal distortion at high volumes, but the Audioengine A2+ Wireless manages to maintain a cleaner profile when pushed to its limits. The Edifier R1700BTs are loud and clear, but they can start to lose composure when the volume is turned to very high levels, especially in the lower frequencies.
Value and Verdict
When considering value, the Audioengine A2+ Wireless speakers are typically priced slightly higher than the Edifier R1700BT. This difference in price can be justified by the Audioengine's superior build material, additional connectivity options, and arguably more refined sound. However, for those who are budget-conscious and prefer a stronger bass presence, the Edifiers represent a solid choice that doesn't compromise on overall sound quality.
In conclusion, the choice between the Audioengine A2+ Wireless and Edifier R1700BT speakers boils down to personal preferences in design, connectivity, and sound profile. Audiophiles looking for precision and clarity with the versatility of modern connectivity may lean towards the Audioengine. Meanwhile, those who favor a warmer, bass-forward sound and a contemporary design might find the Edifier R1700BT a perfect match.
Ultimately, both these speaker systems are leaders in their class, offering exceptional sound quality and functionality in an easily accommodated form factor. Whether for desktop listening, a small room sound system, or as a part of a more extensive home audio setup, each offers a compelling case for being the centerpiece of your audio experience. It's a testament to the fact that high-fidelity sound need not come from giant, floor-standing towers, and that sometimes, the best things really do come in small packages.
Check Current Prices:
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.