Edifier R1700BT vs. Polk T50

Speaker Comparison

When it comes to creating the perfect audio experience, enthusiasts often find themselves at a crossroads, selecting between the compact, versatile design of bookshelf speakers and the powerful, room-filling sound of tower speakers. The Edifier R1700BT Bluetooth Bookshelf Speakers and the Polk T50 150 Watt Tower Speakers represent two contrasting approaches to home audio. On one hand, the R1700BTs are a modern, compact solution, while on the other, the T50s embody the traditional floor-standing speaker design aimed at audio purists.

Design and Build

The Edifier R1700BT speakers boast a sleek, classic bookshelf design with a modern twist, featuring a black vinyl finish complemented by a contrasting wood panel. They're compact, easy to place, and have a contemporary vibe that matches well with different decors. In contrast, the Polk T50 tower speakers stand tall with their slim, elegant profile. Outfitted with a wood grain finish and a removable fabric grille, they evoke a more traditional speaker aesthetic and command more presence within a room.

Connectivity and Convenience

When it comes to connectivity, the R1700BTs shine with their built-in Bluetooth capability, allowing for seamless wireless streaming from various devices. This feature is particularly appealing for those who value convenience and a clutter-free environment. The Polk T50s, however, lack Bluetooth functionality, which could be a dealbreaker for users who prioritize wireless connectivity. Instead, they rely on traditional wire connections, which while limiting in terms of placement, may appeal to purists who prefer a hardwired audio connection for potentially better sound quality.

Sound Quality

The sound signature of the R1700BTs is pleasantly warm and balanced, with a robust midrange that shines in vocals and acoustic instruments. However, being bookshelf speakers, they have inherent physical limitations that affect their bass response and overall power output when compared to tower speakers. The T50s, with their larger size, naturally produce deeper bass and can achieve higher volume levels without distortion. Their soundstage is expansive, lending itself well to both music and home theater setups, where the scale and depth of the sound can truly envelop the listener.

In terms of technical specifications, the R1700BT speakers are equipped with a 19mm dome tweeter and a 4-inch bass driver, which work together to deliver a satisfying sound within their range. The Polk T50s pack a more powerful punch with a 1-inch silk dome tweeter, two 6.5-inch bass radiators, and a 6.5-inch mid/woofer. This combination not only allows for a wider frequency response but also supports the T50s' ability to fill larger spaces with sound.

Value and Versatility

For those who consider versatility and value to be paramount, the Edifier R1700BT is a clear winner. These speakers offer great performance for their size and price point, and their Bluetooth connectivity adds to their user-friendly nature. They are exceptionally well-suited for small to medium-sized rooms and are an excellent choice for those who want good quality sound without the bulkiness of larger speakers. On the other hand, while the Polk T50 may require a higher investment and more space, they are a solid choice for audiophiles looking to fill a large room with high-fidelity sound.

In conclusion, the choice between the Edifier R1700BT Bluetooth Bookshelf Speakers and the Polk T50 150 Watt Tower Speakers boils down to the listener's preferences, space considerations, and usage. The R1700BTs offer modern features, such as Bluetooth and a compact size, while the T50s focus on traditional, high-quality audio performance in a larger format. Whether you prioritize convenience and modernity or the classic audiophile experience will guide your decision in selecting the right speaker for your sonic landscape.